Relevant costs for alternatives
Content revised on 3 October 2026. Any completion marker earned before this revision refers to the earlier content version and does not confirm completion of this revised lesson.
Learning goals
- Identify future cash differences, sunk costs and opportunity costs.
- Compare make-or-buy and special-order alternatives under explicit capacity assumptions.
- Explain why an allocated fixed cost may not be avoidable.
Assumptions and scope
- All entities, data and monetary units (MU) are fictional. No taxes, financing costs or regulatory reporting implications are modelled unless expressly stated.
- One-period decision; capacity and avoidability as stated; supplier price includes delivery; no tax, transaction fees or unstated quality differences.
Relevance belongs to a decision
A relevant cost is a future cost that differs between the alternatives being considered. Both conditions matter. A past payment cannot be changed by today’s choice and is a sunk cost. A future payment that occurs under every alternative is also excluded from an incremental comparison because it cancels. This does not make those amounts unimportant in all contexts; it means they do not explain the difference for this particular decision and horizon.
An avoidable cost disappears if an activity is not undertaken. A fixed cost can be avoidable when a contract can be cancelled, and a variable cost can be unavoidable for a commitment already made. Therefore “variable” and “relevant” are not synonyms. Read the facts about future obligations instead of selecting costs by their accounting labels. Allocated head-office costs often remain after a product or department closes; removing the allocation from that department is not the same as removing the organisation’s payment.
Include what is sacrificed
Opportunity cost is the benefit forgone by using a resource for one alternative instead of its best feasible other use. It may not appear in the accounting records. Spare equipment with no alternative use can have zero opportunity cost for a short-term decision, while a fully occupied machine may sacrifice contribution from existing customers. Include that lost contribution, not the lost revenue alone, because the displaced activity also avoids its own variable costs.
Materials already owned need careful thought. Their historic purchase price is sunk, but using them may prevent a sale or require replacement for another planned use. The relevant amount follows the actual alternative use. Likewise, “idle labour” is not necessarily free: wages may continue either way, but extra hours, fatigue, training or a new commitment can create incremental costs.
Compare alternatives on one consistent basis
In a make-or-buy decision, compare avoidable internal costs and any opportunity cost with the supplier’s total incremental delivered cost. Keep unavoidable internal costs on both sides or remove them from both. Do not include them on only one side. For a special order, compare incremental revenue with incremental costs, including order-specific fixed costs and displaced contribution if capacity is scarce.
A numerical advantage is conditional. Supplier reliability, specifications, staff consequences, confidentiality, quality and strategic dependence may change the decision. Name material concerns rather than assigning invented MU values to them. Where a concern is a non-negotiable requirement, treat it as a feasibility condition before ranking financial outcomes.
Finish with a concise recommendation that identifies the horizon, the advantage and the assumptions that could reverse it. A relevant-cost calculation supports a choice; it does not authorise a purchase, a closure or a staffing change. Longer-term decisions may make previously fixed commitments avoidable and require a broader model than the short-term cases used here.
Worked example: Make or buy a component
For 1,000 components, internal variable cost is 8 MU each. A dedicated 2,000 MU supervision contract is avoidable if production stops; allocated head-office cost of 3,000 MU remains. A supplier offers all 1,000 delivered components for 11 MU each. No alternative use of freed capacity, no quality difference and no other costs.
Solution
Relevant make cost = 1,000 × 8 + 2,000 = 10,000 MU. Relevant buy cost = 1,000 × 11 = 11,000 MU. Making is 1,000 MU cheaper. The 3,000 MU allocation is excluded from both alternatives because the organisation still pays it. If freed capacity could earn more than 1,000 MU contribution, the comparison could change.
The unchanged 3,000 MU head-office allocation is outside both relevant totals.
| Cost item | Make MU | Buy MU | Relevant reason |
|---|---|---|---|
| Variable manufacture | 8000 | 0 | Avoided if bought |
| Dedicated supervision | 2000 | 0 | Contract is explicitly avoidable |
| Supplier delivered cost | 0 | 11000 | Only if bought |
| Relevant total | 10000 | 11000 | Like-for-like comparison |
Independent practice
-
An extra order for 200 units pays 18 MU each. Extra variable cost is 12 MU each and one-time setup 500 MU. Spare capacity exists and normal sales are unaffected. Find incremental profit.
-
A machine bought years ago for 9,000 MU can be sold now for 1,200 MU. Using it for a proposed job prevents that sale, and it will have zero value afterwards. Identify the relevant equipment cost.
-
Buying would avoid 6,000 MU internal cost but cost 6,800 MU. Freed capacity could earn 1,100 MU contribution elsewhere. Find the advantage of buying.
Practice answers and reasoning
-
700 MU.
200 × (18 − 12) − 500 = 700. The setup is relevant even though it is fixed for this order.
-
1,200 MU opportunity cost.
The historic 9,000 MU is sunk; the 1,200 MU cash receipt is forgone if the machine is used.
-
300 MU advantage.
Avoided internal cost plus alternative contribution minus purchase cost = 6,000 + 1,100 − 6,800 = 300.
Common errors to avoid
- Treating allocated cost removal as a cash saving.
- Including sunk purchase prices in a current alternative comparison.
- Ignoring opportunity costs at full capacity.
Exit check
-
Is every fixed cost irrelevant?
-
Should displaced sales be charged at their full revenue?
Exit-check answers
-
No.
An order-specific or avoidable fixed payment can differ between alternatives.
-
No, when their variable costs are also avoided.
Use the contribution lost under the stated model.